[P4] FW: [SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos] Paper #66 "High speed packet forwarding compiled..."

[Leskó Dániel]

Sziasztok!

  A Sigcomm demo video-nak mi legyen a sorsa? Jelenleg egy teljesen 
külön aloldalon van, link nem mutat rá sehonnan.

Dani

2016.06.08. 7:10 keltezéssel, Sándor Laki írta:
>
> Fyi
>
> Sony Xperia™ okostelefonomról küldve
>
>
>
> ---- Eredeti üzenet ----
> Tárgy: [SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos] Paper #66 "High speed packet 
> forwarding compiled..."
> Küldve: 2016.06.08. 0:15
> Feladó: SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos HotCRP 
> <noreply at sigcomm16posters.hotcrp.com>
> Címzett: Sándor Laki <lakis at elte.hu>
> Másolatot kap: 
> marco.canini at uclouvain.be,daniel at land.ufrj.br,chesteve at dca.fee.unicamp.br,panhui at cse.ust.hk
>
> Dear Sándor Laki,
>
> Congratulations. The poster/demo entitled High speed packet forwarding
> compiled from protocol independent data plane specifications that you have
> submitted to SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos has been accepted. We received
> 102 <tel:102> submissions and the TPC has accepted 39 of them.
>
> The reviews and TPC comments are attached below. We will send you an
> additional email with instructions to prepare the camera-ready version of
> your manuscript, which is due June 21.
>
> You can also access your reviews through the website:
> https://sigcomm16posters.hotcrp.com/paper/66?cap=066atXs4RzoZ4G4
>
> Thanks again for having submitted your work to SIGCOMM '16 Posters and
> Demos.
>
> - Marco, Daniel, Christian, Ben
>
> ===========================================================================
>                  SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos Review #66A
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Paper #66: High speed packet forwarding compiled from protocol independent
>            data plane specifications
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                       Overall merit: 4. Accept
>
>                       ===== Comments for author =====
>
> This abstract describes a P4 compiler that translates to C using the 
> Intel DPDK. Data-plane programmability in general, and P4 in 
> particular are hot topics. However, there is a lack of open-source, 
> publicly available compilers and tools available. This could be a 
> valuable contribution, and an interesting demo.
>
> I would suggest you make a strong editing pass over the abstract to 
> fix English and grammar mistakes.
>
>        SRC - Problem and motivation: 4. Good
>
> ===========================================================================
>                  SIGCOMM '16 Posters and Demos Review #66B
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Paper #66: High speed packet forwarding compiled from protocol independent
>            data plane specifications
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                       Overall merit: 3. Weak accept
>
>                       ===== Comments for author =====
>
> The paper/poster shows the approach to develop a high performance P4 
> (programming protocol independent packet processors) compiler. The 
> compiler works by seperating HW independent from HW dependent sections.
> The compiler/demo will show that a P4 program (L2 switch, L3 router, 
> etc) can be compiled to Intel DPDK enabled NIC and results in high 
> performance.  However, the compiler/demo is currently limited to only 
> Intel DPDK, which does not give evidence to the main goal of multiple 
> targets.  Further, there are other P4 compilers that were not 
> discussed from Xilinx (PX), Netronome, etc.  Further, it was not clear 
> why a different hardware abstraction library (HAL) was needed and why 
> the high level intermediate representation (HLIR) was not sufficient.  
> Also, what was the tradeoff of using other intermediate 
> representations to accomplish the same goals such as openCL, LLVM, etc.
>
>        SRC - Problem and motivation: 4. Good
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> P4 mailing list
> P4 at plc.inf.elte.hu
> https://plc.inf.elte.hu/mailman/listinfo/p4


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://plc.inf.elte.hu/pipermail/p4/attachments/20160609/19a1afce/attachment.html>